Rabat – French lawmakers are set to vote on April 16 on a government-backed draft law that has sparked strong debate over free speech, antisemitism, and criticism of Israel.
The proposed legislation, often called the “Yadan law” after MP Caroline Yadan, is based on the idea that hostility toward Israel is closely connected to antisemitism. Its preamble states that “hatred of the State of Israel is now inseparable from hatred of Jews,” a claim that has divided politicians, lawyers, and rights groups.
The government argues the law is needed to respond to rising antisemitic acts in France, home to Europe’s largest Jewish population. Reported antisemitic incidents in France have increased sharply since October 7. More than half of anti-religious acts targeted Jewish people, AFP reported.
The draft law expands France’s existing offense of “apology for terrorism” to include speech that “implicitly” justifies or downplays acts considered terrorist. It would also criminalize calls for the “destruction” of any state France recognizes, with penalties of up to five years in prison.
Earlier versions of the bill were even stricter, as they included banning comparisons between Israel and Nazi Germany and restricting speech about denying a state’s existence. Those provisions were removed after France’s highest administrative court raised legal concerns.
Prime Minister Sebastien Lecornu has strongly supported the bill, arguing that modern antisemitism is often disguised as anti-zionism. He said criticism that describes Israel’s actions in Gaza as genocide can distort the memory of the Holocaust and harm Jewish communities in France.
However, the bill has triggered opposition from across the political spectrum. Left-wing parties, including the Greens and France Unbowed, say the law risks criminalizing legitimate criticism of the Israeli government. They warn it could blur the line between antisemitism and political expression.
Human rights groups have also raised concerns. Nathalie Tehio from the French Human Rights League said linking Jewish identity to the State of Israel could actually increase antisemitism by creating confusion and backlash. “In reality, it equates French Jews with Israel – which is dangerous in and of itself, as this very equation fuels anti-Semitism,” she said.
Legal experts argue that France already has strong laws against inciting hatred and glorifying terrorism. They say the new bill may not be necessary and could be too broad in practice.
The debate has also raised questions about freedom of expression. Critics say the law could punish speech about political solutions such as a single shared Israeli-Palestinian state or calls for major political change in the region.
Supporters, however, insist the law is necessary to address a new form of hatred and to protect France’s Jewish community at a time of rising tensions.